Have a little debate going on here among family members and I hoped some of you knowledgeable folks could chime in.... we were looking at comparing these 2 great power hitters and wondering which player you would prefer if you were assembling a team of Hall of Famers and you needed a power hitting LHB corner outfielder, who would you take between McCovey & Jackson? The first instinct for a lot of people is to say Jackson right away based on his World Series highlights and he hit more HR's (563 to 521). Neither were exactly Gold Glove caliber defenders but in general in their prime Jackson was a better defensive player and McCovey was really more of a 1B than an OF, but he did play OF, too, thus this discussion/debate based on a hypothetical assembling of a team. Jackson struck out a lot more. In fact I believe Reggie has the MLB all-time SO record. McCovey got on-base more too (career .375 to .356), and McCovey had a better career OPS too (.889 to .846)..... and it is believed that McCovey's power numbers were hurt by a career playing in San Francisco The argument for Jackson when looking at the numbers is that Jackson had a steeper decline after age 35 and in his prime Jackson was better than McCovey in his prime, though I'm not sure that is cut and dried.... thoughts on this? thanks