You are the General Manager of the Milwaukee Brewers. You are given the chance to acquire one of the top three young players in the game: Manny Machado. Mike Trout. Bryce Harper. Or, you can pass on those three young superstars, and sign Jean Segura to a long term deal. How you're able to get these players isn't really isn't important. This is purely hypothetical. Here is a side by side comparison of their production thus far (numbers not updated for Wednesday's games). http://img577.imageshack.us/img577/5201/2zg.png Who do you add to your team? Or, do you choose to keep Segura, and sign him to a long term contract? For me, this is a really difficult call. Jean Segura has shown more power than I anticipated at a young age. He can hit for average, and he's highly successful when stealing bases. For his career, he's got a near 91% success ratio, and he's 23 of 25 this year (92%). Defensively, he's a Gold Glove waiting to happen. He's got incredible range, and a rocket arm. If I have the chance to sign him long term, I think I take it. Superstar shortstops don't grow on trees. Of the three players I could have, I'd probably take Machado. I think there's more power coming yet. He's already showing great hitting abilities, and defensively he's incredible at third. I heard something mentioned a few weeks ago on MLB Network-Machado just seems "smooth". Trout and Harper are spectacular talents, but I worry about their durability, Harper especially. Machado puts himself in a position where he can minimize the wear and tear on his body. Harper has the best pure power potential in the game. He and Giancarlo Stanton both have 50 + home run capability. However, if Harper doesn't learn how to pace himself, he'll become the second coming of Mickey Mantle with all the injuries. You have to believe this scare with the knee swelling gets through to him. He can't play like Pete Rose all the time. Harper might have the best arm strength of the three players. Trout is the wild card. He's got the best pure speed, and I don't see him losing a step any time soon. Like Segura, he plays a premium position (center field. This is where the Angels need to keep him). Trout could be a 30 HR 50 stolen base every year (he's successful about 90% of the time), and hit .290 to .310 every season. He's a real weapon atop the lineup, and he's got a fine OBP (.399 last year, .384 this season). What would you guys do, and why?