I don't know what it is, and that's kind of the whole point. When there's reasonable doubt in a court of law, the accused person is supposed to be found innocent. Now, binding arbitration is obviously not a criminal or civil court. But the same logic applies. What if Braun were innocent? Braun's been tested all through his time in the minors, and in the Major Leagues. I've never seen Braun suspended, so it's likely all the tests he's taken in the past have been clean. You can draw two conclusions: 1.) he's been cheating all along, and has somehow been able to cover his tracks so that every test he's taken have come up clean (masking agent, etc). Or, 2.) all his tests have been clean because he wasn't using any illegal substances. Braun gives yet another urine test. Figure this is the fourteenth, fifteenth, sixteenth test, I don't know. Pure speculation. But this time, the collector does not follow procedure as agreed upon by both MLB and the player's union. It is not refrigerated, and is in a private residence for almost two days. It is then shipped, and tested, showing abnormally high levels of testosterone. And not just high, but 2-3 times higher than any test result that's been ever seen. Baseball is, of course, going to pursue a suspension. But the problem is, after the appeals process has played out, the man that holds the tie breaking vote, a man who has almost two months to look over all the evidence, sides with the player. If it were just a cut and dry issue-procedure wasn't followed-and that was the reason for the overturn, it wouldn't have taken Shyam Das seven weeks to reach his decision. There is a very clear reason why chain of custody is so important. Because if a sample is mishandled, it could conceivably ruin a man's reputation, and career. An innocent man could be subjected to unprecedented scrutiny in the court of public opinion. When you take everything collectively-the failure to follow procedure, the leak of the appeals process, which was supposed to be confidential--there are just too many things that stink. Now, is it possible that Braun used? Absolutely. But when everything is examined objectively, I'm seeing a lot of goof ups. The collector of the sample could have taken it to a Fed Ex, as he was required to do. He just didn't. There were several between his home and Miller Park. There was at least one nearby that was available for drop offs 24 hours a day, and he would have known it. I'd be very curious as to why he didn't follow procedure. And it's ironic to me that this man, who has been employed by MLB for so long, just happens to hold a sample for an extra 48 hours (iirc) that later turned out to have a damning level of T.