That is not a compromise I'm willing to make, myself, though. I think Hall should be the starting SS because of his sheer athletic advantages and demonstrated skills that go along with that athleticism at what is easily the most important/busy position on the infield. I'm an idealist, I suppose. You don't think Hardy could back up at 3B or 2B, periodically? If not, why not? Let Hardy pick up the scraps while the just-earned guy starts at the busiest position on the infield. That's my take. Should be an interesting season next season, though. I am encouraged by Hardy's at-bats the past few months. http://forum.brewerfan.net/images/smilies/happy.gif