Bottom line, Greinke is a bonafide ace... 100% (unless he gets hurt). In my view, you don't trade someone like that for basically a coinflip, unless you are hopelessly out of the race AND have no chance at extending Grienke. I fail to see a legit reason that the Brewers can't do the latter. So instead they let him walk so they can win what, 4 more games this year? If those 4 games are the difference between the playoffs and no playoffs then you keep him. But with the injuries and the lack of production we're seeing....something is going to have to majorly change for me to believe this team is a playoff team. I like Greinke as much as the next guy and really wish he'd re-sign, but at some point you need to be real. If he is going to leave, and Melvin will have a better idea about that than anyone of us, and you aren't going to make the playoffs then you'd be dumb not to trade him. Milwaukee has got to start maximizing the value of the some of their players. If Milwaukee doesn't make these trades then it is likely that over a two year period Milwaukee will have lost Fielder, Greinke, Marcum, and KRod and gotten nothing more than 4 draft picks in return. You can't sustain a franchise like that. Now, if the Brewers are 9.5 games out in mid July and Grienke demands a trade or something, I'll do that deal yesterday. I don't think anyone really disagrees with this. I'd use the more official all-star break which is early-mid July but it's essentially the same thing. I'd say if Milwaukee is 8 or more games out by the all-star break we start listening to offers for Greinke, Marcum, KRod, Weeks, and Hart. Not saying you trade all of them, just listen to offers and take the good deals.