Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Jopal78

Verified Member
  • Posts

    4,818
  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

Milwaukee Brewers News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospect Rankings

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Milwaukee Brewers Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Milwaukee Brewers Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Jopal78

  1. The organization’s entire problem is nobody has ever had to work with a roster with less than Hall of Fame play at the QB position. They have only ever know having that guy at the most important position who’s own play can almost single-handedly make up for mistakes around them week in and week out. Love is a terrific QB, but he’ll never meet the expectations following Favre and Rodgers
  2. With guarantees and prorated bonuses they’re stuck with Love and Parsons until 2028. Moving on before then, the amount dead money would dictate the rest of the roster. Besides the money, they’re only 13 months from their declaration to the league that they had Super Bowl talent when they added Parsons as the finishing piece. No matter how bad it is on the field this season they’re not going to hit the reset button; because it would also mean admitting they were not as talented as they internally believed when they acquired Parsons. They’ll do what they always do and blame injuries then fire some assistant coaches like Butkus and Stevanich.
  3. Yes, ready to drop a few grand on a team that’s perpetually good. The reality is 20% of the league doesn’t sell out as it is. The Titans, Jaguars, Jets, Falcons Cardinals and Panthers are all known for futility the better part of the last decade and they all have soft demand for tickets with even some of their openers not being a sell out this year. You don’t really believe the Packers would be immune to that reality if their fortunes went down the same path. Heck, the Steelers might be the most analogous team to the Packers in terms of consistency and they had a less than capacity crowd for week one.
  4. You’re right by saying “bad year”. What I’m saying is 5-7 years of being a doormat, and it’s likely your number is probably close to coming up (if you’ve got the upfront user fee they charge plus the money for all the tickets). It’s a bad mix of being very expensive to go to a game, the tickets are sold on an all or nothing basis plus meaningless pre-season. It’s the nature of pro sports: an amazing tribal experience to let the good times roll, but the lean years people find other things to do with their time and money.
  5. For the last 30 years a ticket holder can sell the tickets at a profit regardless if they go to the games or not. Why would anyone give that up? Good teams = strong demand for tickets Bad teams = lower demand for tickets It is that simple. Two people cannot get into Lambeau Field together for less than $300 and that will continue to go up most years (and that’s for the bad seats). The businesses and tavern owners who have blocks of tickets aren’t going anywhere, but no doubt regular fans aren't going to continually poor their disposable income into a bad product when they can watch it on TV at home for virtually nothing.
  6. Nah, fans are fans. At the end of the day money talks, and people will find better things to do with their money if the team went in the toilet for an extended period of time.
  7. Maybe, but it would be out of character for pro sports teams wherein demand for tickets stays hot when the product on the field is bad for an extended period of time
  8. I do not. What were the ticket prices then? (In 1994 the average ticket price was $26). It’s $150 just to get in the door now, and only going to get more expensive.
  9. It would be non-existent with about 5-7 years of poor play maybe less. Not too many folk are going to burn a couple thousand dollars a year in order to watch them get pounded week in week out, and in cold weather, etc etc. if they went back to an era of prolonged irrelevance
  10. Even if they go 1-16 they are not going to eat multiple seasons of guaranteed coaching salary.
  11. Gotta keep the fans pouring their money into the Titletown District with a known product.
  12. He’s not tradable in that he’s not established/successful enough to warrant the picks in a trade that would make hitting the reset button at QB enticing.
  13. Parsons would demand a trade/release. He’s not going to waste his prime years on a rebuild.
  14. I don’t disagree with you, but again, the organization’s hands were tied the moment they traded for Parsons. You don’t trade two first round picks and a player for Parsons, give him 136 million dollars guaranteed to then fire your HC and GM less than 6 months later and bring in someone else to run a core they didn’t build and are not free to dismantle. It “can” be done but it puts an organization in Raider/Brown territory to do so.
  15. No. I think in every post about it I said May hasn’t pitched well. I dispute the notion that it’s some awful trade that they were foolish to make. There is an obvious reason why they made the trade. Even with May making it a six man rotation their other starters are running on fumes. imagine asking that group to absorb another 31+ innings on top of what they’ve already thrown. Dump on May as being crappy, but he came with 464 major league innings, a 1.23 whip, 2:1 K:BB ratio, and 1 HR/9. They acquired an established major league starter who hasn’t performed as hoped. That makes the result disappointing to date, it doesn’t make the decision to acquire him foolish. It is also a false equivalency to look at some AAA ERAs and conclude the Brewers simply could’ve got the same production by shuttling a collection of AAA arms back and forth assuming minor league stats translate seamlessly against major league hitters .It also ignores the practical roster and workload problems trying to manufacture 30+ innings that way. Finally, it’s treated as almost a guarantee they’ll someday regret trading Frias and Ragsdale. Maybe they’ll both be perennial All-Stars for most of a decade, or maybe they’ll be the next Joey Wiemer. That uncertainty is the entire point. Prospects are possibilities, not future major leaguers held in escrow. The only way this becomes an obvious disaster is if you assume the most flattering possible future for the prospects and the least flattering possible present for May. That’s not evaluating a trade; it’s writing the ending first and pretending the evidence already exists.
  16. Sure, Parsons’ performance isn’t the problem; it’s that the other players around him are not good enough. The pro-rated part of his bonus makes it impossible for the Packers to move him in any way (even for picks) before 2028. A new GM before 2028 would be expected to win while still using Gutekunst’s core, instead of a full rebuild. Plus with Love and Parsons taking up 33% of the cap, there will not be room to sign difference making FAs.
  17. But it kinda wasn’t the point to win surplus value was it? They didn’t win the surplus value with Wily Adames either FWIW. It’s fun baseball talk stuff but teams don’t really make decisions based solely on surplus value
  18. If your conclusion from 31 innings is that Dustin May and some anonymous AAA shuttle arm were interchangeable, you’re not evaluating the trade—you’re reverse-engineering an argument from a bad month. A proven major-league starter struggling for six weeks does not magically turn every organizational depth arm into the same caliber of pitcher. And calling Ragsdale and Frias a “massive package” is prospect-hugging at its most absurd: two interesting prospects, neither of whom had played above Double-A and neither of whom had demonstrated anything in the majors, are being treated as though Milwaukee traded away established big-league stars.
  19. Well, apparently, the front office disagrees with your armchair assessment of the AAA carousel but hey the A’s and Astros are looking for GMs so not all hope is lost just yet. Admittedly, May has not pitched as well as anyone expected. But what I assume you purposefully ignore the reason that Pannone, Stallings, McGee, Hardin, Crow etc. have spent almost all of their careers in the minor leagues while May, except for injury rehab, has not been in the minor leagues since he was a 21 year old kid: physical talent and ability. The “AAA carousel” might have been able replicate May’s aggregate so far, but it was not an equivalent bet. Milwaukee bought a much higher degree of certainty that the pitcher taking the ball belonged in the major leagues. And for a first place team trying to protect Misiorowski, Henderson, Gaser etc, certainty itself had value. They were buying a legitimate MLB starter, so they didn’t have to find out during a pennant race whether their 29 year old AAA guy was one.
  20. Haha, as if you (or I) could get outs in the major leagues, give me a break. Love ‘em, hate ‘em May and Romero are bonafide major league players who have had plenty of success in the major leagues and have given the Brewers exactly what they needed: a pitcher to absorb starts while the rest of the rotation dealt with workload/injury issues, and another left handed reliever with leverage experience. That trade doesn’t have to become a long term win to be the correct decision. The Brewers objective never was to maximize their WAR in 2030, it was converting future probability into usable pitching in 2026 for perhaps the best Brewers team ever assembled.
  21. Even if they go 1-16 this year, they’re likely safe. If the Packers fired them both, they’d absolutely have interest in their GM position and HC position (there is only 32 of each), but the Packers probably would not be the first choice for candidates with multiple options. Why? Because Parsons and Love are tied to the Packers through 2028. Any new GM would be expected to fix a roster to compete while being substantially constrained financially by Love and Parson’s contract, missing top draft capital from the Parson’s trade, etc. To fire LaFleur after this season would mean giving a new coach more job security than the GM has, and offering a shorter than usual contract to a HC will disinterest candidates with other choices. The reality is unless a multi-season collapse occurs, both Gutekunst and LaFleur are likely to be with Green Bay through 2028 when a new GM could actually reshape the roster instead of mostly administering the prior GMs decisions.
  22. Is it that they’re chokers, or is it really that they’ve had mediocre rosters for years but with once in a generation players at QB who could overcome poor play around them and win games largely through their own quarterback play?
  23. I bring it up to rib you and because it’s the perfect illustration. The Brewers “won” that trade 1000% they got major league innings for Joey Wiemer who is and was a nothing burger. Right now, despite May and Romero being disappointments the Brewers are winning the trade 1000%. They’re getting desperately needed major league innings when the other two guys combined haven’t even played 60 games above A ball.
  24. Unbelievable Ortiz has his BA up to .270
×
×
  • Create New...