He has a .546 winning percentage with the Cubs, which over the last 3 years would place him behind only Roberts, Murphy and Boone. Hard to credibly argue he hasn’t been successful.
Where you’re spot on though are expectations. Counsell was brought in to manage teams to pennants, and he knows he’s got a leaky bullpen and an offense that struggles to consistently convert runners on base into runs when the home runs, don’t come. Those are the reasons he’s probably pacing in the dugout.