What if we had used Coco last night? Let's say that we use Coco in the 12th and the Reds don't score. We would have had the bottom of the order up in the 13th. What if we didn't score there, do we use Coco for another inning? OK, so Balfour pitches the 14th inning, we still lose, and Coco is not available for tonight. We could have lost two games last night instead of just one. Managers don't know the results ahead of time. A good argument may be made for using Parra instead of Balfour in that situation, but not much of an argument can be made for having Coco pitch that inning. If he is to be used in a tie game then he should have pitched the 9th.