Uribe isn't an effective closer, at least not yet. No team we are playing we are leading by one run in the ninth is thinking "Oh no, here comes Uribe." Uribe has the stuff to be an effective closer but maybe not the mental makeup. If he had not pitched Tuesday, I wouldn't question the move, but he hasn't proven he can be relied on pitching two days in a row. Personally, I would've trusted Megill more if Murphy was going to pull Ashby.