That is quite a dilema, but remember that it's a good problem to have. It's a totally personal choice, mostly depending on what you value in work and your tolerance for risk. But since you asked, here's an opinion. If you're a "hard-charger" and get a lot of satisfaction from achieving things, it sounds like the new company would be a good move. The pay raise, but mostly the career opportunity could be intruiging. That said, you take a risk in going...your co-workers could be jerks, etc. Your current job is a known quantity, which has some value b/c you know what to expect. If you value your "internet surfing time" like I do, you might find that you like your current job and don't need the money or career advancement. I write a lot online and really have to have a time at work to react to those things--that has a lot of value for me. The freedom you have at your job sounds like it's pretty valuable to me, and is something you won't find in a lot of places. If you like your current job and have that kind of freedom, I suggest looking at your long-term goals before making the leap. Don't let a dollar and hour sway your decision. If you're looking for a change anyway, you might seize the opportunity, but if you like your job, think long and hard about the jump.