I wouldn't view it as upgrading Tony Gwynn, I would view it more as replacing Jenkins It may just be semantics, but I see Gross as sliding into Jenkins' roster spot and Gwynn sliding into Gross' at the moment. If they do nothing else, Gwynn makes the team. If they get another guy and don't get rid of anyone else, Gwynn doesn't make the team. Jenkins was at no point not going to make the team, which is moreso the case for Gross coming into '08 than Gwynn. I agree that I would prefer Kearns and possibly Church, but I don't think it's going to be any easier acquiring Kearns, and Church isn't going to come for free either. I'm much more fine trading Gamel for Kearns (and maybe even Church). They are also both on the right side of 30. I don't love Kearns' contract, but at worst he's $2.5 mil less expensive than Winn and has a better OBP.