Worked good the other years, why fix whats not broke? MLB tried to conceive of some NL vs. AL showdown in home runs which I dont think works that well for a home run derby. The players each side brought were not necessarily the best home run hitters. I think the fans should vote for the home run derby participants because I think can do a better job at picking than MLB or the players. Give the fans the right to pick Home Derby Participants while sacrificing the ability to vote for the all star game. I certainly do disagree with almost all the players Fielder brought. I dont think Weeks should have gone, or Halliday. Kemp was the only guy i thought would do good (and I was obviously wrong). I dont know if it was the ballpark or the players but there was just a lack of home runs hit this year. Physics were on the players side this year with the high elevation so I'm thinking it was the players.