Started this one knowing another Hiura thread is out there, but tying this with Adames…
First off, I was fairly surprised, not shocked, that Hiura was sent down several days ago. I figured he had some good games at the end of June and especially in July. In fact even now, his OPS is way higher than anyone’s in July (1.194) and .OBP too (.480) in limited appearances (24 PA). End of June wasn’t bad either. For a broader look, his yearly OBP (.354) and OPS (..805) should be considered extra good for him sure, but really almost anyone! How he was sent down had to be because of his almost 47% K rate. His pinch hitting status was awful because of it (4 AB, 4 Ks) too against high heat late relievers. Yet, I fail to understand how Hiura, with his limited defense, was sent to the minors while Adames hits in the #2 spot in the order about daily!
Adames’ numbers are positive with spin when looking at HRs (20) and RBIs (54). His awful numbers overall are more concerning. His AVG. (215), and OBP (.289) are awful. Think about that. Is this #2 hitter stats? He needs to play, I know, as our SS. I am thankful that we have him. But does this scream #2 hitter? Put him at #7 or 8.
Concluding, I feel Hiura could easily be on this team as a DH right now and part time 1B/2B. His overall numbers have actually been better than Adames, especially when talking about having a top of the order bat. Late June and July even help his case. If strikeouts and contact are your hang up, pinch hit him late innings with Brosseau. If his defense gets you down, play him DH or sub for him late. In a complex move, I’d like to see Hiura up for Caratini since Severino has no options remaining. However, I’d like Caratini back up in September as the backup when rosters expand to 28 players. Also, Severino cannot be on the postseason squad by rule of his suspension, yet he could be valuable to the team come 2023 with Narvaez likely gone via FA.
Overall, I’m just not understanding the roster and lineup shuffle now. Adames needs to move way down in the order, and Hiura, after showing some signs of life (and while in Nashville), needs to be back up. His .OBP and power are being wasted so Adames can set the table (.289 OBP) for the heart of the order. And if Hiura isn’t your cup of tea, still get Adames out of there and move a hot bat (like Urias—- .July 286 AVG, .373 OBP, and .873 OPS ) up.