What did you find to be the issue with that thread? It looked like a lot of members echoed Brian's concerns, and people gained a lot of clarification (e.g. "what is considered a one-liner?"). Hmm. That doesn't really strike me as "the Brewerfan.net Way." The aforementioned thread started out with, "Let me start by saying that I am always open to suggestion, and constructive criticism as to how we run Brewerfan.net are always welcome." Let it be clear, I think the policy is just fine, and I'm not suggesting any changes. I just thought I'd speak up in case anyone has any concerns or, especially, questions.