He was always totally disposable. They needed an arm and he was one they could just dump the next day. Also, when you're as borderline of a rosterable reliever as Godley is, you can indeed lose your job off a really bad 1/3rd of an inning. Brent Suter is not going to lose his job off a bad third of an inning. Neither is Brad Boxberger. Someone like Godley has no margin for error. He needed to at least give the team something to feel good about with his outing, and he did not.