My take on the whole "Braun lied/didn't lie" situation is this. Regardless of EXACTLY what went down, and only one person knows that, MLB still controls who gets to play. Nobody has a RIGHT to play major league baseball - it's their ball, they let you play with it. The HUGE black eye that MLB suffered as a result of procedural errors and/or loopholes that they hadn't ensured would be watertight, meant that someone had to pay. Had Braun ever seen the inside of a court room, as others have alluded to, good legal defense could have gotten him off on a technicality, or planted enough seeds of doubt as to whether he actually had taken PEDs. Maybe he's lying when he said he never took PEDs, or maybe he's lying when he said he had, because the alternative was being told that his career was over. Ultimately, MLB still has the final say on who gets to play, a la Shoeless Joe. Marge Schott, who also brought the game into disrepute - she faced a ban. I have no doubt that the witch hunt against Braun - in particular given Selig's need to show he wasn't biased towards the Brewers, would have dragged on. Braun, not wanting to risk his career ending there and then, fell on his sword, either because he knew he was guilty, or actually WAS innocent, but didn't want to lose a charge of being, in Landis's words, “no longer a fit companion for other ballplayers.” It reminds me of the scene in A Few Good Men where the Marines are exonerated of the crime they are accused of, but still don't get to be Marines anymore. Either way, the hatred for Braun would have been far less had he been a "cheeky chappy" like Manny being Manny, or a club icon like Pete Rose.