It's fine to have questions. It's another thing to invent scenarios. I don't know what happened. I can think all the things I want. I can even post them or say them out loud. But there is a line, and some of the things I've read and heard in various places (and I'm not just talking about Brewerfan.net) seem to me to be crossing the line. It's even fine to cross that line, wherever that line is. Just don't be annoyed if someone in turn calls out comments as perhaps crossing that line. I haven't named any names or specific comments. Just putting it out there that sometimes speculation simply isn't fair, and it certainly shouldn't be passed off as idle, impersonal banter because it's more than that. I've known guys who have broken their hands before and who didn't know it was broken. You can get hit on the back of your hand and have it be sore and swollen and then in a day or so it's not a big problem anymore. Luc has probably had his hands beat up plenty and played through it. It's a rare professional catcher on any level who hasn't. He may well have gotten hurt, thought he could deal with it like all the other times he's gotten hurt and then he couldn't go. It would be just as easy for him to be reticent to say anything about getting hurt in some stupid, innocent accident as it would about any other way of getting hurt. It's just as easy to believe that a guy who has been banged up before wouldn't necessarily know his hand was broken if he's dealt with worse that hasn't been a break. I don't know what happened. Maybe it all happened the way it's been presented, maybe it didn't. But to characterize the explanation as a "story" in the sense that it's simply a construct for public consumption just bothers me, even more so when people then turn around and use that characterization as an excuse to construct their own "stories". But then I once hit my wife in the head with a hammer (a glancing blow to the scalp, but it drew blood and an ER visit) while we were demolishing our first kitchen. She came around the corner and walked right into my followthrough. You're scared and feel awful, and then you have to deal with a bunch of people who are wondering if what really happened is all just a "story". I can deal with the fact that quite often you don't know what to believe. What I don't much like is that fact that it seems like a lot of people don't even WANT to believe.