Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Brewer Fanatic Contributor
Posted

Every November, a new wave of prospects becomes eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, and teams must decide which players they want to add to their 40-man roster to shield them therefrom. Front offices have many factors to consider, including (but not limited to) talent, proximity to being MLB-ready, investments already made into a player, and the likelihood that another team might select them—the last of which is, obviously, closely tied to the first two. As a reminder, any player selected during the Rule 5 Draft is required to remain on the active MLB roster of the acquiring team all season (or be waived and then, if unclaimed, offered back to their original team), making it a high threshold to cross for most unprotected players.

According to Roster Resource, the Brewers' 40-man roster currently includes 34 players, and they have 31 minor leaguers who will be eligible for Rule 5 selection if they aren't added to the roster. There will be many easy decisions and a handful of tough choices that need to be made. The Brewers eliminated one of their would-be dilemmas on Sunday, by trading Blake Holub (who would have been Rule 5-eligible, and still might be for his new team) in the Ryan Walker trade. Here's how the rest of their decisions shake out.

Expect these players to be added (4): Jett Williams, Luke Adams, Matt Wood, Cameron Wagoner

Jett Williams was a top 100 prospect just last winter and one half of the Brewers’ return for Freddy Peralta. He will almost certainly be given an opportunity to show that injuries were the main reason for his down season in 2026. With experience all over the infield and outfield, he would provide solid depth to the Brewers' 2027 roster. Luke Adams missed a large chunk of time for the second season in a row, but he put up a very strong showing in Triple-A Nashville when he was available, with a .259/.418/.509 line and 13 home runs over 279 plate appearances. Adams will be in the mix at first base to replace Jake Bauers, though he's far from being guaranteed a spot.

Last November, the Brewers chose not to protect Matt Wood, leaving him eligible for the Rule 5 Draft in December 2025. He wasn't picked, but after a strong 2026 campaign, he probably would be this season. Wood has yet to reach Triple-A, but surely, a number of MLB teams could improve their backup catcher situation by inserting Wood, who hit 18 home runs with a .257/.398/.492 line over 386 plate appearances in Double-A. Wood continued to impress with his patience at the plate in the Arizona Fall League, drawing 14 walks and carrying a .456 OBP. The Brewers might roll the dice on a team not wanting to call a catcher straight up from Double-A, or they might trade Wood to a team more ready to use a 40-man spot on a minor leaguer, but the most likely outcome is that they add him to the roster.

Cameron Wagoner had a breakout season in 2026. Wagoner made 33 appearances split between Double-A Biloxi and Triple-A Nasvhille, pitching 42 2/3 innings with a 1.48 ERA and 59:11 strikeout-to-walk ratio. Wagoner might be in the running for the top overall Rule 5 pick if the Brewers leave him unprotected. He's exactly the type of player who gets taken most often, because he's almost certainly ready to contribute to a big-league bullpen right now. The Brewers will probably add him to the 40-man roster instead of allowing that to happen, and the team will have his full complement of minor-league option years (3) to support the MLB club as needed in 2027 and beyond.

Toughest Call (1): Brett Wichrowski

Since being drafted in the 13th round of the 2023 MLB Draft, Wichrowski has bounced up and down Brewers prospect lists. He's flashed plus raw stuff at times and looked lost at other times. Given his arm talent, he could be selected by a team and used in low-leverage situations while continuing to develop at the big-league level. To avoid losing him, the Brewers could protect him now and trust that he will be able to contribute during the 2027 season, but the guess here is that the Brewers will value the roster flexibility and risk losing Wichrowski, betting that if a team takes him, they'll be unlikely to keep him on their active roster the entire season and would ultimately have to return him to Milwaukee.

There is a chance (4): Tate Kuehner, Mike Boeve, Damon Keith, Ethan Murray

Kuehner had a very good 2025 season with Biloxi and looked like he would be on track to make the roster by this point, but he missed nearly three months in the middle of the 2026 season, and when he came back, he was striking out fewer batters and walking more. Another team with serious pitching needs and less to compete for in 2027 could take a shot on Kuehner, but that's a risk the Brewers will probably be willing to take. That said, if the Brewers fill the entire 40-man roster, Wichrowski and Kuehner are the most likely last two players added.

Boeve spent the entire 2026 season at Double-A, hitting 9 home runs in 510 plate appearances, with a solid batting eye. He bats left-handed, which would make him a natural complement to Andrew Vaughn, unlike Luke Adams. However, Boeve lacks a real defensive position and ideal power for the corners or DH. The combination of having not reached Triple-A, not providing positive defensive value anywhere, and having multiple corner infield prospects ahead of him within the organization leaves him off the 40-man this winter, and he probably won't be picked, even if the Rule 5 Draft does happen. (Remember, there's a chance that the lockout will cancel it.)

Damon Keith has real power that could play in the current outfield mix in Milwaukee, especially as a right-handed batter. On the other hand, Keith didn’t make it past Double-A in 2026; he missed a large chunk of the season; and he hasn’t shown that he can make contact consistently enough to access his power at the highest level. The Brewers will be pleased if he goes undrafted and they can carry him as outfield depth in Nashville, which is probably exactly what will happen. Ethan Murray, a 2021 5th-round pick from Duke, had a solid 2025 season in Double-A but did not hit last year in Triple-A. Murray plays very strong defense all around the infield and therefore could latch on as a utility glove for an MLB team, but it's a long shot. He's been left unprotected the last two years, and the Brewers haven't regretted that yet.

High-profile draft picks who probably won’t be added (3): Brock Wilken, Eric Brown Jr., Dylan O’Rae

First-round draft picks Wilken and Brown have had disappointing careers to this point. Wilken has shown big power at times and put together a solid season at Double-A in 2025, but he took a step back this season in Triple-A. It would be a surprise if another team selected him. Brown was drafted as a shortstop, but spent 2026 playing all over the field. He'll probaby get the opportunity to continue developing as a utility player for the Brewers in Triple-A next season. O’Rae, a 3rd-round pick in 2022, had a solid season at Biloxi and has 125 stolen bases over the last two years. It would be a major stretch, however, for another team to think they could carry him on their active roster for the entire 2027 season, and therefore it’s highly likely that he will get a chance to continue developing with Triple-A Nashville.

Very unlikely to be added (19): Edgardo Ordonez, Tayden Hall, Mark Coley II, Luis Castillo, Manuel Rodriguez, Wande Torres, Daniel Corniel, Will Rudy, Cole Phillips, Will Childers, Edwin Jimenez, Jesus Broca, Ryan Birchard, Joshua Quezada, Anthony Flores, Jose Meneses, Jason Woodward, Quinton Low, Anfernny Reyes

A number of these players participated in the Arizona Fall League. Check out Cory Sparks’s grades for each. Birchard seems to have consistently intrigued the Brewers; they've sent him to the AFL multiple times and appear to still believe more can be unlocked. Torres is a big left-hander with lots of projection left. Meneses and Quezada are interesting, too, but so far away from the majors that there's no chance they'll be taken.

The Brewers continue to be one of the deepest organizations in baseball, and the roster crunch for next winter’s 40-man deadline will be even more daunting. Too many good players is usually a good problem to have, though, and even the reigning World Series champions know it's probably not one they'll have for all that long.

Image courtesy of Rick Scuteri-Imagn Images

View full article

Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't see any way Wichrowski gets added. I think your list of 4 is pretty good but the team usually protects less than what is expected.

  • Like 1
Posted

Id be surprised to see Wood protected. 
 

If they did, would they non-tender Naylor? Not sure they need to carry 4 catchers on the 40 man all winter. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I think teams might end up protecting fewer than usual, figuring there is a chance the Rule 5 draft gets canceled. My tiers:

Likely, but not locks this year: Adams, Williams, Wagoner.

Coin flip: Wood

Would be a coin flip other years: Kuhner

Plausible, but highly unlikely: Torres, Wichrowski.

I would even put Meneses ahead of any of the other hitters.

  • Like 2

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...