billy hall debate

[TURBO]

seriosuly, what is the reason so many here think he is so special?

yes, he had a decent season 2 years ago, but if he left, I wouldn't feel good or bad. I just wouldn't care.

I think the guy is our most over-rated player we currently have, as far as the fans are concerned anyway.

just my opinion, but I can't believe all the love for him on this site, he is an average player, that would not even start on most major league rosters.

fire away!

Edited March 3, 2008 by 1992casey

[TURBO]

seriosuly, what is the reason so many here think he is so special?

yes, he had a decent season 2 years ago, but if he left, I wouldn't feel good or bad. I just wouldn't care.

I think the guy is our most over-rated player we currently have, as far as the fans are concerned anyway.

just my opinion, but I can't believe all the love for him on this site, he is an average player, that would not even start on most major league rosters.

fire away!

Edited March 3, 2008 by 1992casey

[TURBO]

seriosuly, what is the reason so many here think he is so special?

yes, he had a decent season 2 years ago, but if he left, I wouldn't feel good or bad. I just wouldn't care.

I think the guy is our most over-rated player we currently have, as far as the fans are concerned anyway.

just my opinion, but I can't believe all the love for him on this site, he is an average player, that would not even start on most major league rosters.

fire away!

Edited March 3, 2008 by 1992casey

[TURBO]

seriosuly, what is the reason so many here think he is so special?

yes, he had a decent season 2 years ago, but if he left, I wouldn't feel good or bad. I just wouldn't care.

I think the guy is our most over-rated player we currently have, as far as the fans are concerned anyway.

just my opinion, but I can't believe all the love for him on this site, he is an average player, that would not even start on most major league rosters.

fire away!

Edited March 3, 2008 by 1992casey

[dadofandrew]

Considering Koskie "sucked", I'd say Hall is in very good company. As a guy capable of playing 2B, SS, and CF; his career numbers are well above average at all three spots.

 

Not much sense saying much else.

[dadofandrew]

Considering Koskie "sucked", I'd say Hall is in very good company. As a guy capable of playing 2B, SS, and CF; his career numbers are well above average at all three spots.

 

Not much sense saying much else.

[dadofandrew]

Considering Koskie "sucked", I'd say Hall is in very good company. As a guy capable of playing 2B, SS, and CF; his career numbers are well above average at all three spots.

 

Not much sense saying much else.

[dadofandrew]

Considering Koskie "sucked", I'd say Hall is in very good company. As a guy capable of playing 2B, SS, and CF; his career numbers are well above average at all three spots.

 

Not much sense saying much else.

[brettac1]

He'd probably start for at least 20 teams at SS alone. He had a down year last year, but it's not like he's ridiculously paid, he's a bargain.

[brettac1]

He'd probably start for at least 20 teams at SS alone. He had a down year last year, but it's not like he's ridiculously paid, he's a bargain.

[brettac1]

He'd probably start for at least 20 teams at SS alone. He had a down year last year, but it's not like he's ridiculously paid, he's a bargain.

[brettac1]

He'd probably start for at least 20 teams at SS alone. He had a down year last year, but it's not like he's ridiculously paid, he's a bargain.

[TURBO]

and what good did Koskie actually do for us?

 

Hall is just an average player imo... in fact, I'll give you above average since he is so versitile position wise, he just doesn't excite me...

[TURBO]

and what good did Koskie actually do for us?

 

Hall is just an average player imo... in fact, I'll give you above average since he is so versitile position wise, he just doesn't excite me...

[TURBO]

and what good did Koskie actually do for us?

 

Hall is just an average player imo... in fact, I'll give you above average since he is so versitile position wise, he just doesn't excite me...

[TURBO]

and what good did Koskie actually do for us?

 

Hall is just an average player imo... in fact, I'll give you above average since he is so versitile position wise, he just doesn't excite me...

[PeaveyFury]

Koskie was having a great year for the Brewers before the freak injury.

[PeaveyFury]

Koskie was having a great year for the Brewers before the freak injury.

[PeaveyFury]

Koskie was having a great year for the Brewers before the freak injury.

[PeaveyFury]

Koskie was having a great year for the Brewers before the freak injury.

[tomter38]

Keep in mind Bill's numbers last year were pretty awful while he was trying to play through his injury.

[dadofandrew]

Last I checked, a team of average players would win 81 games and each make about $5M.

 

I wish I was average.

[tomter38]

Keep in mind Bill's numbers last year were pretty awful while he was trying to play through his injury.

[dadofandrew]

Last I checked, a team of average players would win 81 games and each make about $5M.

 

I wish I was average.

[tomter38]

Keep in mind Bill's numbers last year were pretty awful while he was trying to play through his injury.