One thing I haven't seen mentioned: Even if it was a good decision to pull Peralta (Which it wasn't, and I will die on that hill) to replace him with the likes of Dan Vogelbach is laughable. It isn't like were replacing him with a guy hitting .275, hell, .250. The odds of Vogelbach getting a hit in that situation were minimal at best. He just isn't the type of hitter that makes pulling your starter after 4 innings, with 51 pitches, and dealing, a good, sound decision It was a bad move. It was a bad decision on so many levels, and I get people sticking up for CC, but there have been times where he has made really stupid decisions, and this is one of them. It doesn't mean CC should be fired, or that he sucks, or is a moron, it just means he made a REALLY bad decision in a playoff game, that in the end, could cost us the series. Is it a "start Kotsay in CF" type of mistake? Right now, after still hurting from the loss, I'd say yes it is. I may feel differently tomorrow, but I doubt it. It was a bad decision. Lastly, the time to flip the switch is running out.