Defense, yes. Intangibles, no. Weeks is a far superior athlete &, in terms of success rate, is an elite basestealer Being a superior athlete doesn't qualify Weeks as being a great basestealer/baserunner. How many times has he been doubled or picked off? How many times has a middle infielder duped him from taking an extra base by simply acting like they had the ball? Is Weeks a great athlete? Definitely yes. He can steal bases with the best of them, too - but he is severely lacking in baseball instincts. He's still very raw and may very well develop into a solid baseball player, but right now he's not even close...I'd call him a toolsy guy that hasn't learned how to play the game yet. It's tough to consider giving up on him, but it's also tough watching him repeatedly make the same rookie mistakes that he's made before. Two things I wish Weeks would do more often offensively/on the basepaths - bunt for basehits and slide feet first. Sliding in feet first doesn't slow runners down as much as you'd think if done properly, and the runner can get a much better view of where the ball is in case it gets away from an infielder on an errant throw. Weeks pulls the ball so much that you almost never see the 3B playing him in - why not drop a bunt down from time to time to take advantage of that? with his speed, if Weeks gets an average bunt down that the pitcher/catcher can't field easily he has a hit, and can probably turn that into a double with a stolen base. You never see him try to bunt for a hit, though.