We decided to stay in Fish Creek. We had narrowed down our search for a B&B/inn/cottage to 2 places (Thorpe House Inn and Whistling Swan Inn), but both places require a 2 or 3 night stay, and they just ended up being too expensive for us. I dont want to spend $320 on 2 night's sleep when we won't be spending a huge amount of time in the room. I think we are going to stay at the Fish Creek Motel. From what I've read, the only knock on the place was that the rooms are old, but it has been completely remodeled since then (<1 yr ago). The location appears to be pretty much perfect for us. If anyone has any comments on this place, I'd appreciate it. And thanks again for all of the suggestions I have gotten. Some of the places on our agenda we got from BF.net are: - Bayside Tavern - Shipwrecked Brewery/Pub - Al Johnson's - Peninsula St Park - Summertime Restaurant One thing I am having trouble finding is a good place to horseback ride (besides the Kurtz Corral)