An F? For a team that made the playoff? Yikes. I could understand b/c range, but this is a bit harsh. Yes his last offseason deserves an F because nearly all his moves were terrible. There was absolutely no reason to think that some of the guys he brought in were going to be so bad. Garcia and Narvaez, specifically, had solid track records and looked like nice pickups. A few guys were obviously just fillers with the hopes they could be productive. A couple others like Phelps and Gyorko were very good signings. I mean, you win some, you lose some. The problem was that some of the ones he "lost" were both very unexpected and exceedingly terrible. (besides, we don't know if things would've been different in a normal season)