It's gonna be pretty hard to find GM that meets your criteria (sub .500 ball). Maybe the Red Sox agree with you, will fire Theo, and we can hire him. Who should be GM of this team? Until there's a better option, I think you stick with Melvin. And I'm not counting on the Terry Ryan pipedream, personally. For all of the "sky is falling talk" on this board, at least this team has talent and could turn things around. The Brewers had almost zero when Melvin got here. Weeks, Braun, Fielder, McGehee, Escobar, Gallardo....the pre-Melvin Brewers would have killed for any of these guys in the lineup. Not to mention the farm system. Call it mediocre now. It was a wasteland then. Maybe Melvin isn't the long-term solution, but he was far from a failure.