My point is that he's not shown that he's better than Helms as a starter. Most of his at bats are in spot duty. When he was given the starting job his numbers fell - same with last year - he hit .271 in July, .244 in August, .222 in Sept. As a result his OPS went from .859 to .812 to .788 These are not bad numbers by any means, but my opinion (and it could be proven wrong and if he does I will be the first to admit it) is that given an everyday role, we can't expect him to have an .800 OPS I'll grant you that he gets his share of extra base hits, but so does Kieschnick. Can we expect Brooks to maintain his 1.061 OPS all year? No, and that's why I'm not in favor of starting him either. His role is pinch hitting which puts him in a position to succeed.