I don't think I'm overreacting at all. Thornburg was pitching at AA yesterday, and tonight he's facing one of the toughest lineups in the majors. We got 5 great innings out of him. Asking him to go through that lineup a third time was asking for trouble, and that's what we got. Thornburg will be a great pitcher for us, but we were expecting too much for a guy that's pitched 10 games in AA to come in and pitch six or more innings at the Major League level. I have to say I agree... You would expect a manager to be able to figure this stuff out on his own. It sometimes seems like RR is learning on the fly, except, that can't be true because he never makes corrections to the stupid things he does. He just keeps doing the same stuff over and over and over and over. Before the 6th, I told my son that Thornburg should come out, avoid the loss, set him up for a possible win, and let him go to sleep tonight knowing he pitched a hell of a game against one of the most potent line-ups in the league. Instead, he is now dealing with disappointment instead of pride. If I can figure that out, why can't he? Common sense really, which is always lacking in our dugout. Thonburg was at only 75 pitches and hadn't been struggling. He wasn't on some low pitch count. No way in hell would i have pulled him before the 6th and i doubt other managers would have either, much less to put in that scrub Dillard. Zero reason to. As for him "dealing with disappointment instead of pride", come on Turbo, i'm sure he's a big boy an will handle it fine. If he can't, he isn't long for the majors because big league hitters beat up all pitchers. It's part of the job description. Dust yourself off and take the ball five days later.