He demoted a far better player than Kendall Because he had an option who could be better defensively and shouldn't be that much different than what Hardy had already been hitting. to get rid of another guy whose crime was merely hitting as poorly as Kendall the golden boy He should have been gotten rid of, as that level of hitting is unacceptable at any other position. In other words, guys who can't catch don't catch, thus the spread in defensive abilities from the best catcher to the worst is not nearly as large as one would believe. Since you believe in this weeding out process, there is probably a good reason why Salome and Rivera aren't replacing Kendall, as they are obviously better hitters.