i think melvin has done a slightly above average job for landing talent. ---i do not like at all any way the gane signing. many closers emerge every year throughout MLB. total waste of money to be spent elsewhere. ---i think the brewers bench players are below average, and do not give any sense of urgency that a starter may lose his job. weak bench. the minor league system is static right now, except for laporte. yes, a strong draft may be on the way, but immediate help to the bigs seems to be non-existent. trading seem to be his strong suit, except for linebrink, but it was an attempt to help when needed overall grade--C+, maybe B- with a big grading curve. the thing is other franchises get better, win, then get torn apart, and rebuild again, and get better--oakland, cleveland, florida, come to mind--all mid type markets. this prolonged slump since 1992, or 1982 (take your pick for your starting point) is really getting tiring. so i say, melvin is definately on the hotseat until this franchise wins...wins something, anything other than a sausage race. the brewers have to win at least as many games as last year or melvin is gone for sure.