Many of the major sports websites have published filler articles that "rank" or "grade" all of the MLB teams' offseasons. Very seldom do they have any credibility. For example, SI.com's Jon Heyman ranked the Cubs offseason 9th and the Brewers 20th. It's almost impossible to compare two teams' offseasons because of their different needs, but everyone who is baseball-savvy enough to post here knows that. But still, I'm a bit surprised by the scepticism by the national media about the Brewers. An extra starter could still be dealt, but the odds are that the haul would be prospects unlikely to contribute this year. So I think it's time there's a thread to see what the real experts' thoughts are about Doug Melvin's offseason overall. This isn't necessarily meant to be a direct comparison with the Cubs, but more an evaluation of the moves that were made over the winter. Are you happy with what has been done? Have the moves he has made handcuffed any future moves? And most importantly, do you think that the talent level has been improved enough? Personally, I am pretty happy with DM's offseason. I was really surprised to see some of these breakdowns say things like, "the bullpen lost Closer Francisco Cordero, but the overall performance shouldn't drop too much." I really think this bullpen is much better than it was last year, there's plenty of depth. All you need to know is that Chris Spurling and Greg Acquino were on last year's opening day roster. This season, one or two very worthy candidates for the pen will start the year in triple A. The last option out of the pen will likely be a starter. Even Solomon Torres, projected as the 6th inning man, has closing experience. Melvin signed David Riske for a smaller contract than Scott Linebrink signed. Signing Mike Cameron was a logical move and was definitely the best available option to fill in the last offensive spot. Of course, DM gets extra points for bringing back Russel Branyan. I anxiously anticipate an announcement that Joe Winkelsas has been brought out of retirement. http://forum.brewerfan.net/images/smilies/smile.gif And the great part is, aside from the Riske deal (pun intended), no money is tied up beyond this year, putting the Brewers in great position to make more moves next winter. Say what you will about Gagne, Kendall, Torres, Cameron, and everyone else, but if any of them are bad this year they leave and their money can be put towards other positions and locking up guys like J.J. Hardy who are their arbitration years. I think this post has gone on long enough now. What are your thoughts about the offseason?