Yeah, but now you're punishing the school for the decision of the player to stop playing football. When I said to guarantee the 4-year scholarship, I meant to guarantee it so long as the player wanted it. I don't think you can make a strong argument that it'd be fair to punish the school if the player turned pro, quit, got into trouble...etc... Why not. Scholarships are an incentive to the student athlete to go to a particular institution. Why doesn't it make sense that the scholarship stays with the student athlete for the four or five years they are completing their degree. It would be hard to argue that Kentucky did not know what they where getting when they signed Tyler Herro a couple of years ago. One and done, right! On the other side of the equation, I don't see why these institutions of higher learning should be used as minor leagues for the NBA, NFL or any other pro league by the student athlete. It would be hard to argue that Tyler Herro did not know his future intentions when he sighed with Kentucky. One and one, right. Maybe two and done. There was always the G League/Europe for Tyler to do his thing. He would have still ended up as a first rounder. I think the NFL should create their own G League and stop using the NCAA as a minor league. My whole point here is to say when you sign a contract for four years, shouldn't you honor that contract for four years? The institution should give the scholarship freely for four years to the athlete to complete college studies in return for the student athlete giving four or five years on athletic participation. I my example of Kentucky/Herro both sides of the equation knew how the each other where acting.....with less than average integrity. Both sides broke there four year commitment to each other willingly and in your face. Look at it this way, Herro would be helping Kentucky as a Junior this year to a much better record if he was faced to honor his contract. Why did Kentucky let him go? It is just what college sports has become...a severe lack of integrity by both institution and student athlete. Last thought....Make the institution and the athlete honor their contract. Make college sports what they are suppose to be....sports of college student athletes.