The real question is whether or not you would support Chuck Finley for the HOF because he is almost the same player as Pettitte: Finley: 3.85 ERA 1.376 WHIP 467 GS 3197 IP 2610 K Petit: 3.88 ERA 1.357 WHIP 479 GS 3055 IP 2251 K Pettitte's only advantage is he walked less hitters 2.8 BB/9 vs 3.7 for Finley, he gave up less HRs 0.8 HR/9 vs 0.9 for Finley, and all the postseason stuff which is only because he played in NY. Finley better peak years, top 6 years in WAR: Finley 7.5, 6.6, 6.3, 4.6, 4.4, 4.4 Petit 7.6, 5.8, 5.7, 3.3, 3.3, 3.3 And overall lead with 55 WAR to 50.2 for Pettitte Finley also had 63 CGs and 15 SHO vs Pettitte's 25 CG and 4 (!) SHO. But Pettitte went 240 - 138 while Finley went 200 - 173 so Pettitte looks better but they are really the same player. Finley got only 1 vote for the HOF but Id guess Pettitte gets somewhere between 10-20% of the vote on his first try.