however in the long run the statistical model is going to be correct on a more frequent basis. I think the burden of proving this to be true is on you here. I thought in school they taught people to give evidence of their work . I think it's called supporting a thesis. I don't have the energy to show you all the analysis, data, and muscle that went into my opinion (which was presented as fact - but who doesn't do that nowadays). I'll just point you to the 2009 Milwaukee Brewers pitching, then to the 2010 Milwaukee Brewers pitching, and Macha's record as the Milwaukee Brewers manager. That's where I started. Not in 2006 or 2008 or 2001. I just looked at last year and this year, ages of players, factored out best years and worst years, looked at regression patterns, contract amounts (believe it or not, the more you make the worse you do on average - could have a lot to do with older vets getting their due from unsuspecting GMs, save a few special players), how much I like some of them, add in a bit of fear factor and luck. The rest is a secret.