(Ultimately, I think most folks are fine with him having a day off, although I'm skeptical of whether it would actually do any better than just letting him try to play through his slump.) At this point, any production is better than no production. If this was Gamel (pre-injury) battling like this, Ishikawa would be spot starting or someone else sure would be. Take away the name (Weeks). Pretend you were the manager. If you had a starter hitting .170 on the year and second in the Majors in strikeouts, and you had a competent backup on the bench, wouldn't you sit that guy for a game to clear his head, let him take a day off from everything, and perhaps kick start his offensive game? At what point do you start to worry about Weeks? Do you seriously want a guy pressing and getting nothing out of it, batting .170 and hittin gin the #1 or #2 slot in your order? My idea. Move Hart up to #2 and drop Weeks down to #5. Give it a week and see how it goes. It really couldn't hurt. Neither guy is really hitting the ball well right now. I see Corey swinging and missing a lot. Why not get some runners on in front of the guys who are actually hitting right now? If you are going to be this stubborn, as a manager, and let a guy work out of this prolonged slump with no off days, then why not switch up the lineup. And Lucroy needs to stay right where he is at.