I think you are mixing up "clutch" with his general struggling at the present time. It's not that he isn't coming up short in late game situations only. No, I'm not mixing anything up at all. He's struggling, and he's not clutch. Two different assessments, both germane to the subject at hand. He's not clutch, therefore he should not be in the #4 slot. He's struggling, therefore he should be moved down to the bottom of the lineup, and not just out of the cleanup spot.