With a one run lead, 2 batters can do more than plenty of damage. They can and did but if you're going to assume the worst case scenario no move is good. Coffey wasn't a good option and there was a pretty persuasive showing above that DeFilice wasn't a measurably better option either so I'm still OK with it. I guess I'm still baffled that it wasn't DiFelice. There were 2 RH hitters due up. He has pitched one whole inning in the past week. Is he so much only a RH option, that he can't come in even when there's the threat of a LH hitter to pinch-hit? I guess if he was being saved for Pujols, after Stetter came in for the LH, I could understand. But it was Coffey, so why didn't it start out Coffey. As you can see, I'm a bit confused. Usually in a one-run game in the 9th, the best pitcher not named Hoffman would be your answer. And DiFelice, Stetter, and Coffey are all better than Villanueva right now.