This is called playoff baseball and you have to give a little of the future to improve the team. Linebrink has always done a solid job in the setup job, a couple of bad outings will always skew his stats because of the lack of innings pitched. I posted an article on the Linebrink trade. I touched on the point you made above in that article: The third, and perhaps most important, is that Linebrink has been even less impressive this season [than in 2006], to the point where he has been pretty average. His home run rate is way up and his strike out rate is way down. When looking at his 2007 numbers, it should be pointed out that Linebrink's wife is due to delivery a baby. His number over his last three outings in San Diego covering 2 2/3 innings, Linebrink has allowed five hits, two home runs, seven earned runs while walking three and striking out two, for an ERA of 27.00. That said, those two poor outings don't explain why he is only striking out 5/9 innings or why his home run rate (excluding those two hit near the end of July) is 1.48/9 innings. Those numbers could well be the sign of a pitcher on the decline or a pitcher just having a rough year. While I understand it is important to note that a few of Linebrink's poor outings could well be related to his wife's pregnancy, that doesn't explain why, for the whole season, his strike out rate is lower than Spurling's, or why he is giving up home runs at a rate higher than any current Brewer reliever (well, as of when the article was written over the weekend). Even 1.5 home runs per nine innings is high for a guy that pitched so much at PETCO. I think the addition of Linebrink does make the team better, but mostly because it adds depth. At the very least he is very unlikely to have too many outings like Balfour had. I don't believe he is really any better than anyone they have on the roster right now unless he reverts back to his 2004-5 form. And if that's the case, I fear he is going to be of less help than we might have initially thought.