You are not alone in your disbelief in Dickinson and it's hard to get jazzed about a 100 mph HR to CF as a 3rd on his season. BUT he is seeing improved results and that means something. Regardless of latching on solely to big names, when the org depth players start producing it is noteworthy and worthy of celebrating, imho. As someone who cares about the players, and who wrote ML reports for many years, I personally think using 'stinky' when the team has seen fantastic results since losing real Blue Chippers is a strange approach. BUT, that may just be me. I'm not trying to, nor do I want to, change your mind on any of this. Just offering my own opinion. I don't think anything you said above is incredibly obvious, btw. I don't think other posters did either.