He can handle it in a pinch. It's not a super natural fit. He won't hurt you there because he's just a very good athlete but he really doesn't have the ideal arm to make it work over the long term. I think we have to be realistic here: Collins has played well over 400 games in the Minors. He has 13 starts at 3B. He could fill in for a game here and there, no doubt. But, is he a serious 3B candidate in the ongoing contemplations and lineup prognostications? I don't think so.
The topic being overlooked in general, however, is Collins can absolutely step in and play 2B should they move Turang to SS. It's his best position, defensively, by a pretty good amount. Throughout his Minor League career 2B and LF were near equals in terms of exposure and innings. In my humble opinion, 2B is his best position by a significant stretch. His athletic traits play well there. Is he Turang? Absolutely not. But, he's also not Tyler Black.
Collins has been my guy on this board since the summer of 2023. AND, this being said, I might be crazy, but I still live in a world where I allow myself to see Cooper Pratt surprise us all and make it to the Bigs by mid-summer. Obviously, this all depends on how the hands are dealt and what 'The River' card is when that deadline nears BUT that young man is 100% a manager's dream. He is 100% every inch of the 'steal of the draft' he was touted on draft day and by the organization's top development peeps. I'll continue to be comfortable envisioning a possibly more aggressive path than I originally did if I continue seeing what I did all of last year in his first full-season as a Brewer.