No, you haven't stumbled through a wormhole and traveled back to the Brewerfan.net debates of Spring 2005. My question is, if you have to trade one, and keep the other as the starting SS for the foreseeable future, who would you trade and who would you keep? Shortstop seems like a pretty justifiable place for Hall to get playing time, which is what he wants. Hardy has been pretty bad for about a year now.