I don't believe that there is definitely a better defensive CF in MLB than Gomez. You could make arguments for a few guys - Gutierrez, maybe Bourn - but there is no one definitively better. He makes boneheaded throws now and again, but no one is perfect, and he's better than most everyone despite his faults. He's worth a tremendous amount on defense. And FWIW, it seems he's taking a slightly better approach at the plate this year. Fewer out of zone swings, more in zone swings, generally just swinging a bit less. It's also important to remember that he's 25 years old. I think that a lot of people truly don't know how young he is. Lorenzo Cain is 25 years old, too. No one here was too quick to run him out of town, yah? The things that drive me nuts with Gomez are his baserunning miscues, complete inability to bunt and Roenicke batting him second. Now that we seem to have taken care of the 3rd issue, let him hit 8th (or 9th) and play great defense. He's worth a lot. He really is.