I don't know. IMO Carlton Fisk was the better player of the two. But, you could make an argument for both getting in. And you could make an argument for neither deserving to be in. At the end of the day, I guess Fisk deserved to be in and Simba.... hmmm.... hem, haw, hem, haw... I'll say no, but I wouldn't scream if they selected him. By the way... the article link that presents this scenario from the earlier post really understates the difference in their defensive abilities. Carlton Fisk was a much, much, much better defensive catcher than Simba. And that very well might be the difference maker in the end.