Door B. You take the WS win. With 30 teams in the league, you're gold if you can win one in a decade. I think most people would take the guaranteed WS, including Mark A. But that's not how the game works, because no one can guarantee a championship. And the best way to win a championship is getting into the dance as often as possible with the best team you can afford. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. The heart of this.... you can structure your team to be like either door. One way, you maybe never go overboard with a FA signing, never trade away that top prospect, never trade the future for present because the goal is to be the year in, year out darlings, making the playoffs every year. The other way, you know that you are a little fish in the gigantic ocean. You are the littlest kid playing king of the hill. Your shot at standing on top of that snow hill by yourself does not come often, and when it looks clear, take the moment, push that fat kid off, throw your hands up, and enjoy it before you are piled on top of and thrown back to the bottom quickly. Sign the big name FA the year after winning the wild card with a young/cheap nucleus, trade away some top pick for the present ( seriously, don't you now think Melvin should have traded MORE of the future in 2011 now knowing we didn't make the playoffs the last 5 years? Could we have won it with another piece or two... Furcal? A legit #5 hitter?). I believe the Brewers best way of winning a championship in the unfair MLB is to get a talented, young, cheap core group packaged together with big name FA and aggressive trades for a two, three year shot at winning it all before FA erodes the core.