Well, as far as Love goes, my point wasn’t to say that he’s a failed pick (though I’m probably a little less certain of him being the franchise QB of the next 10 years than I was a year ago), but to point out, having him sit multiple years required us to pay him franchise QB top dollar money after very little on field production. There was hardly any rookie QB contract to take advantage of.
As far as the other examples, you stated repeatedly that it’s hard to find certain instant production late in the 1st, which may be fair, but the main examples of the 1st round projects in Gary and LVN, weren’t late 1st round picks.
In the case of LVN there were certainly other, better prospects available with a better chance to contribute in their rookie seasons.
Christian Gonzalez and Broderick Jones being the two most obvious examples.