First, let me say that this post is not a concession on my part for postseason baseball in 2022, though I think it is looking less and less likely.
Regardless of what happens, I think we need to take a step back and perhaps consider that we no longer appear to be heading in the right direction as an organization. The 2021 season appears to be more of the exception than the rule. I think there were well-founded fears that if our pitching took any sort of step back from their otherworldly performance from 2021, we could end up with a very mediocre looking baseball team. I think those fears have come to fruition.
Now the question becomes - where do we go from here? We don't appear to be in a position where a full-blown rebuild is necessary, but I think we're also in a position where we need to recognize that adding one or two of the Andrew McCutchen types of the world every offseason isn't really benefiting us in any material way. In fact, one could argue that it is hindering us by taking AB's away from bats like Hiura and keeping up-and-comers like Mitchell and Frelick from receiving their opportunities.
So, what's your plan for 2023? The clock is ticking louder and louder on the Brewer careers of players like Burnes and Woodruff. Do we cash those chips in now, or ride them until the very end? I think we have to accept the reality that the 2022 version of Christian Yelich is about all we can realistically hope for going forward. Is it indeed better to endure a 1 or 2 year mini rebuild while we wait on development of some of our prospects and perhaps Jackson Chourio by 2024 or 2025?
I think the most likely option, not that I agree or disagree with it strongly, is that we enter 2023 with largely the same except some reinforcements in the bullpen, and perhaps allowing young players like Frelick and Mitchell and Ruiz to complement veterans like Renfroe and Yelich while moving on from aging vets like McCutchen.
A lot of decisions to be made on the direction of the team this offseason.