This team is never going to have star offensive production at every position. That's just the way the finances work. I'm totally fine not giving up on a defensively gifted 25-year-old who has shown capability, if not inconsistency, with the bat. Plus, with Hiura solidified at 2B, I want a strong defender at SS. Then he'd better step up the defensive part of his game as well. Despite his reputation, Counsell made it no secret that he was disappointed with Arcia's defense in 2019.