As long as there is sun for some point during the day, the snow and ice will melt off. Doesn't matter if it is -15 degrees. As for the cable for satellite debate, I think there is a lot of bad information about there concerning both sides. I switched from Time Warner to Directv 2 years ago because D* offered way more HD channels. Now, TWC has caught up and pretty much surpassed D* in their offerings. Supposedly that will change soon after Directv launches their next satellite on Dec 28th. However, despite the commercials, cable is NOT the home of free HD. Last I checked you still needed to pay for the HD box and also for the HD package if you wanted all the HD channels. Directv has a select group of I believe 6 HD channels that you have the option to pay for. The vast majority are included with your package. On the flipside, I do believe that cable's point of losing satellite signal during bad weather is somewhat valid, especially on the HD channels. During the summer, I lost my signal for maybe 5 minutes a couple of times during torrential storms but it came right back up. The heavy wet snow does indeed stick to the dish and you will probably have to deal with it eventually. As mentioned above, the DVR pricing is a lot better with satellite, on a monthly basis. Where they get you is the activation fee when you get a new box. It still blows my mind that they charge $199 if you want to add a new HD box. Add to that the fact that you are then locked into a 2 year contract, not unlike a cell phone company. That, and you need a box to get their signal vs. just plugging in the coaxial in the back of your TV with cable. On the other hand, I have not once had to replace a box with Directv while with Time Warner it seemed like I was in the store every couple of months getting new equipment. There are over a thousand more arguments I could list here but for me, the equipment and monthly pricing with Directv works. Their customer service is a lot better too. I still have TWC for Roadrunner (which I am happy with) as satellite really doesn't have any Internet options. But, as it stands for me, it is pretty even between the two. Should there be any problems with Directv's upcoming satellite launch I will be forced to switch back to TWC because they have really stepped up their HD offerings over the past few months.