No it isn't: MLB 2B, 2011: .260/.319/.388/.708 MLB 2B, 2012: .253/.317/.381/.699 And like it or not, if you want to buy a player who projects to be average in free agency, you are going to spend around $8-$10 mil. If you assume just average defense, Weeks does not have to have even an .800 OPS to earn his salary. Going forward, he's projected to have a .236/.337/.422 line this year. He can't undo what he's already done (his product was worth negative $, obviously) but if he could reach that modest project and play average defense, he'll earn his money going forward. That's why he's still in the lineup.