As pointed out by others in the Peavy trade rumor thread, I don't like his contract and what it would do to the Brewers budget in years to come. A contract like that for the Brewers is a potential franchise killer. As others have pointed out, I don't really trust Peavy out of Petco Park, although some have made good arguments that its not as big a deal as one may think. From just a "gut" fan standpoint, personally, i think peavy seems like the anti-C.C. Sabathia couldn't wait to get here, put on the uniform, be part of a winning team. We all saw it last year. How Peavy has handled the White Sox trade, his no-trade clause, etc. has just rubbed me the wrong way. If we are going to mortgage the future of the franchise (trading more prospects, committing a ton of money to one player who takes the mound ever five games) I want to see it be for somebody who instills more confidence in me as a fan. And, finally, Halladay is a much better pitcher in my opinion. I'd rather have him on this team down the stretch. Based on all that, I don't think it makes me crazy to say I want no part of him.