I don't think there's anyone on here thinks HY should have just immediately chucked the ball into the Marlins bullpen and said, "Here you go guys." But his embarrassingly juvenile negotiation tactics - asking for bats from other players, tickets to a Yanks-Marlins series in Florida and wearing that stupid Marlins hat to pose as a fan - goes to show he was trying to squeeze the most of his lucky catch. He couldn't have cared less about what that ball means, just what it could get him. The people across the street from us are having a rummage sale. They obviously don't want all that stuff and maybe some of it would mean more to me than it would to them. I'm going to ask if I can just have it. Give me a break. This isn't an issue of monetary value, it's sentimental. If i bought a book from you at a rumage sale, and your kids first grade artwork was in the book, legally it's mine. I bought it. But if you want it back does that mean that I should hold it up until you give me your family car. It's just some kids artwork to me, but it means more to you and your family. Jesus, in reality he should have just handed the ball over, got a picture with him and said congratulations. HY is well within his rights to do what he did. But that doesn't make it the right thing to do.