A couple of points: First, why shouldn't K-Rod finish some games? Think about it. You now have the ability to use Axford say 3 days in a row and still have a quality closer to bring on on day 4 if need be. This isn't a question of NEVER using K-Rod as a closer. It's just about being smart. I have no doubt Ax is the first option at closer. Now they have another option when they need to go there. they will be able to use Hawkins, Saito and Loe in a much more targeeted way. They aren't going to put themselves in position for the option to vest. And they'll keep themselves far enough away from the number to make sure they'll still have the option to use K-Rod as a finisher late in the season. But if you have x number of games to play with, you may as well use them if you need them. That's why you make a deal like this. Second, as much as there have been problems with the pen losing games, a lot of that also falls on the offense to a certain extent. There have been quite a number of games this season in which the offense has simply not supported good/great starts with enough add-on run production. Other than the recent 6-1 debacles this hasn't been a team prone to blowing huge leads. They've just put themsleves in a lot of coin flip situations. They've been very good in the 1-run games. When they've lost late they've lost games where they give up big innings and thus don't skew their own 1-run game stats. Unless K-Rod turns out to be a horrible fit in the clubhouse, or simply fails on the mound, I don't see how this move has any down side for Milwaukee.